Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Feeling the burn every time you shave? There’s nothing worse than trying to clean up that scruff for a sharp look — only to suffer from red, irritated skin and bumps. Aftershave to the rescue! With key ingredients like witch hazel and aloe, your skin will be free of irritation and infection, and it’ll be oh, so smooth. Rub on these aftershave balms for a clean cut with clear skin.

Learn More About Our Top Five Picks:

1. Proraso Aftershave Lotion — $14.00

Best Overall


Pro: It works like a dream, and it’ll make you feel like you’re at an old-school barber shop
Con: It contains alcohol, which can irritate and dry sensitive skin

Bottom Line: This lotion is one of the most trusted aftershaves, thanks to ingredients like witch hazel and eucalyptus, and it comes at a good price, too.

Ever see one of those obnoxious “Italians Do It Better” shirts? After trying this liquid lotion aftershave, we finally get it. There’s a cult-like following for Proraso aftershave balms, and with good reason. Witch hazel and eucalyptus work to reduce inflammation, tone your skin, and clear your pores of dirt and bacteria. When a brand has been trusted and loved by men since the ’40s for that perfect shave, you know you have to try it.


2. Nivea For Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm — from $8.21

Best Budget Buy



Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Pro: It gets the job done at a great affordable price
Con: Users with an oily skin type may experience excess oil and breakouts

Bottom Line: One of the best options you can get, at a low-price that won’t make you think twice.

This is not a drill! The never-ending search for an aftershave to help your irritated sensitive skin is over. While it may be a common thought that the best grooming and beauty products have to be expensive, this non-greasy aftershave balm proves otherwise with a stellar trio of witch hazel, chamomile, and vitamin E. Keep your post-shaving routine simple with this aftershave that moisturizes with a cooling sensation, and it’s packed with anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and anti-aging properties. Cue the slow clap for this all-star balm.


Looking for more awesome affordable aftershaves? We’ve got you (and your skin) covered.

3. Baxter of California Aftershave Balm$18.05

Best for Smooth Skin

Baxter of California


Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Pro: It helps put an end to razor bumps
Con: Expensive

Bottom Line: The high-quality ingredients in this pick make a big difference in the battle against irritation.

Baxter of California packs the dream team of ingredients to prevent razor bumps and irritation in this alcohol-free aftershave formula. While you might be familiar with aloe if you’ve ever had a gnarly sunburn, another ingredient in this product is tea tree oil, which works like witch hazel to prevent acne, lighten skin scarring, and seriously soothe your skin after cleaning up your mug.

Add glycerin (great for combating acne and redness while hydrating skin) and allantoin (fights irritation and stimulates healthy tissue growth), and there’s no razor that can stop you from having perfect skin after a close shave. While there are slightly more affordable options on the market, this aftershave has the great quality Baxter of California is known for, and that’s what made it a men’s grooming go-to.


4. Lab Series 3-in-1 Post-Shave$31.99

Best Splurge

Lab Series


Pro: It does more than just clear your skin
Con: It’s expensive for such a small amount

Bottom Line: If you can afford it, this aftershave will go from being a luxury to a necessity.

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

When you’re having a rough morning, shaving can feel like a chore that you don’t want to deal with, especially if you often get razor burn. This post-shave is a winner! Not only will it give you smooth skin without burn or bumps, but you’ll also notice your facial hair growing slower and softer with a finer texture (aka less shaving!). This one is good for all skin types, but men who are acne-prone will be happy to know this formula includes saw palmetto, which works as an anti-inflammatory. Sea whip extract is another winning ingredient that comes from Caribbean gorgonian coral (where it lives under extreme conditions) to calm and heal skin while fighting aging. There’s a reason this post-shave is a best-seller!


5. Lather & Wood Shaving Co. Sandalwood Aftershave Balm$16.12

Best Scented Aftershave

Lather & Wood Shaving Co.


Pro: Stellar ingredients, without harmful chemicals
Con: The smell isn’t for everyone

Bottom Line: While some aftershave scents barely last, this one lingers longer than the rest.

While you’ll see that most aftershaves have some sort of fragrance in their ingredients lists, most don’t last long or are strong enough to be noticed. However, this winning option holds its woodsy smell all day long. Along with witch hazel, aloe, and vitamin E, this balm also has coconut oil for extra smooth and soft skin. Plus, reviewers say the company has excellent customer service, and a representative of the brand reaches out for feedback with every purchase. No wonder this aftershave is a hit on Amazon!


More of Our Top Picks:

Looking for more? Check out these other aftershaves that’ll turn you into a smooth operator in no time.

6. The Art of Shaving Unscented Aftershave Balm$40

Best Unscented Aftershave

The Art of Shaving


Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Pro: A little dab goes a long way
Con: It’s not as cheap as its competitors

Bottom Line: Keep your manly scent with a seriously smooth and sharp look.

Guys who want to keep their manly natural scent will be happy to discover this aftershave from The Art of Shaving. The effective formula has shea butter to moisturize your skin, and it works as an anti-inflammatory that’s known to help minimize certain skin conditions, like blemishes and irritation. Plus, this unscented balm has vitamin C to give your skin a bright, healthy glow. While the price tag might look high, you get way more balm for your money over our splurge option, and it only requires a small amount per shave.

Learn More

Here are a few more unscented aftershave options if you prefer the fragrance-free life!

7. Prospector Co. KC Atwood Aftershave Splash$16.99

Best Aftershave Splash

Prospector & Co


Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Pro: A citrus- and sandalwood-scented splash, without the alcohol sting
Con: The scent doesn’t last

Bottom Line: The bottle and brand has a charming look with an awesome citrus smell.

This small American business has made a big splash with its great-smelling aftershave. From the cool-yet-simple packaging to the story behind the name of this aftershave (named after the citrus pioneer with the world’s largest grapefruit grove), this post-shave product is as charming as it is effective. With witch hazel (which has astringent properties) instead of alcohol, the splash won’t give your mug a harsh sting you’d expect, while organic aloe works as an anti-inflammatory to soothe the skin.

Learn More


Get a Whiff of the Best Men’s Colognes

The 8 Men’s Body Washes You’ll Want to Rinse and Repeat

The Best Men’s Dopp Kits to Organize Your Gear in Style

Follow on Facebook and Pinterest for all the latest products, so you can find the item that’s perfect for you (at the right price)!